Talk-Polywell.org

.... Just to knock the nail on the head. I think you have this the wrong way round. .... When a reputable scientist comes up tc>When a reputable scientist comes up “reputable scientist” is getting to be a misnomer once you need to specify it ;o) though, the motives are apparent... tc>Just to knock ...

Not much left now but for the name-calling to really get cranked up I guess. Since "science" is clearly not your strong point, maybe that is all that is left? So if Rossi is such a chump you must have some great discoveries to your name Giorgio to speak with such arrogant authority, do tell .... mm...

To summarize the discussion: You link me an experiment you consider "well done" that tried to replicate an effect observed on tungsten cathodes that did't even use a tungsten cathode and looks like it was conducted in about a week by amateurs. It is better conducted than the original Let us be perf...

I guess in many cases some "Sceptics" are looking for the excuses why it is not them. The irony is that the "reword" is so minuscule if LENR saga is failed and it only comforts the "Sceptics", needless to say the benefits of "Sceptics" be wrong. So far, the marketing of the LENR ideas are very diff...

till then i will give them the benefit of doubt You guys must be weakening. Or has the backpedaling started? Before you were all so certain it was fraudulent, fake, criminal or any other insult you could make up, without any proof. I guess in many cases some "Sceptics" are looking for the excuses w...

I wonder what "well done" experiments he is talking about. I have never seen such a report. Perhaps you can link one. http://www.earthtech.org/experiments/Inc-W/Mizuno.html This argument boils down to arguing that the CF experimenters have no idea how to do calorimetry. A much more authoritative fi...

IF the E-Cat works it will transform the world at least as much as Tesla did. Once again: IF grandmother would have penis she/he will grandfather. At least one year you repeat the same "if". It is easy to provide evidence of effect existence but they could not. Instead they have thought up the next...

A good article posted here that makes the various points much bettter than the last many pages of crap from posters on this thread. Andrea Rossi : Sinner or Saint? Is Andrea Rossi the world's greatest inventor since Nikola Telsa and the savior of mankind, or is he one of the worst scoundrels of the...

>That makes it sound like the stupid deserve to be ripped off! It is exactly how world works and it is very ethical and rational from my perspective. Then I guess it would be unethical for someone to forewarn the gullible about a potential scam, lest it prevent them from getting the natural justice...

The one who has money has it exactly for the reason it does not give it away foolishly. Money have tendency to flow along IQ gradient. Before investing a substantial resources any reasonable investor would hire a responsible technical staff to run benchmarks who faces legal consequences for giving ...

I can see how this can go one of three main ways: (1) premeditated scam, (2) self-delusion, (3) Real deal. I do think there is circumstantial evidence to support all three. I guess it bothers me that some are so dead sure of one of three at this point. It's not a case of being dead sure - rather wo...

If Rossi is going to throw out such numbers he should at least do some homework, so that his claims are consistent with each other, or at least a hint of reality. Note that this analysis assumes that his energy out claims are real. Even with this this completely unsupported assumption, his subseque...

stefanbanev, I fell the same way. I'm not sure why these do nothing, paper scientists (few probably have a PhDs as if that makes any difference) have to pile on with the insults. Everyone knows the chances of a revolutionary invention like this actually working is very small. It is a safe bet to ju...

Rossi is not a "scientist" and all his explanations are his "non-educated" compilation/interpretation of different insights he has learned from different "qualified" people, plus I do not exclude intentional/non-intentional disinformation (aftermath powder is on of such possible case another is the...

Oh. Just what specific behavior has given you license to make your libelous remarks? That he won't tell people how his secret process works? Au contraire. He has given about 30 incomplete alternative explanations. Each incommensurate with the others and what we think we already know (physics, chemi...