Diogenes wrote:TallDave wrote:Skipjack wrote:
Where did all the US Intelligent Design believers come from?
It's called "freedom of religion." You guys had ovens for Jews. I don't think you're in position to criticize us on that one.
And we Americans massacred the Indians and Kept Slaves. Oh, wait... That was our ancestors! Maybe we modern Americans shouldn't be blamed for the Actions of our ancestors?
The 1800s? What do you think was happening in Europe at the time? It wasn't all peace and love.
In any case, the 1940s aren't some bygone age. Some of those people are still around today.
The Two most obvious and most serious missteps Paul Bremer made in Iraq were the announcement that No member of the Bath Party would be allowed to keep their Government jobs, and that the entire Iraqi Army would be disbanded.
The former is almost certainly true (deBaathification was overapplied), the latter simply acknowledged reality: the Shia conscripts had all gone home.
It is my opinion that the Methodology of World War II was greatly superior to the Ad Hoc schemes cooked up on the fly by Paul Bremer and George w. Bush.
OTOH, we didn't have to carpet bomb Baghdad or nuke Tikrit. If we had, the occupation would have been much easier, but the cost would have been horrifying.
"Light footprint" was a disaster, but try to imagine the reaction if we had sent in 500,000 troops and put them on every corner in 2003. It would have been called everything from imperial to racist. Of course, we now know it would have worked a lot better, but the conventional wisdom of the time was we needed to be gentle, hands-off conquerors.