Aussies Claim Working Fusion Reactor
Aussies Claim Working Fusion Reactor
Engineering is the art of making what you want from what you can get at a profit.
Their claims are even more amazing than the one of Defkalion:
What can we say. If even one tenth of the claims on a single one of all of these companies will become true, than 2012 is going to be a very interesting yearSpecifically, the reaction is said not to require the high temperature, high pressure or accelerated particles of others’ approaches. “The key is not how many neutron hits you generate, but how you sustain them, how well you can control them.” For a 40-watt power input, the reactor is said to be able to generate a megawatt,” is the quote.
After reading the article, as is surmised in the article itself, the claim is very suspicious.
Concerns not addressed includes the heat load of a MW of power on a 'Rice Cooker' sized vessel. This ~ 1-2 liter volume would result in a high thermal wall loading. Not mentioned is what is done with the neutrons, which would carry most of the energy from a D-T reaction. And, even if you can fuse D-T at such low temperatures and high densities that are implied by such a description, any use of the D-T reaction is completely useless unless you also account for where the tritium comes from, and the energy cost of obtaining it.
Dan Tibbets
Concerns not addressed includes the heat load of a MW of power on a 'Rice Cooker' sized vessel. This ~ 1-2 liter volume would result in a high thermal wall loading. Not mentioned is what is done with the neutrons, which would carry most of the energy from a D-T reaction. And, even if you can fuse D-T at such low temperatures and high densities that are implied by such a description, any use of the D-T reaction is completely useless unless you also account for where the tritium comes from, and the energy cost of obtaining it.
Dan Tibbets
To error is human... and I'm very human.
I agree with all the above comments. Esp the heat load. Conventional cooling is 1 MW/m^2. Above that things get interesting.
Let us say a big rice cooker. 10 cm radius. 20 cm high.
Area of the sides: 2* pi * r * h = 2* pi* 10 * 20 = 1257 sq cm
Area top and bottom 4 * pi * r^2 = 1257 sq cm
Total area = 2,513 cm^2. about 1/4 sq m.
4 MW/sq m. - they are needing some very big pumps for the experiments. Or just run it in pulses.
Let us say a big rice cooker. 10 cm radius. 20 cm high.
Area of the sides: 2* pi * r * h = 2* pi* 10 * 20 = 1257 sq cm
Area top and bottom 4 * pi * r^2 = 1257 sq cm
Total area = 2,513 cm^2. about 1/4 sq m.
4 MW/sq m. - they are needing some very big pumps for the experiments. Or just run it in pulses.
Engineering is the art of making what you want from what you can get at a profit.
Ok, this is even less probably for me than Rossi was originally and waaaay less than he still is to me now (which is back to below 50% due to his dubious behaviour regarding UoB).
I mean there is absolutely nothing to support this story, beyond some hearsay...
I also guess that they dont need that much of it. If the device is that small and they are only testing it in pulses long enough to get the information they need, who knows how little this really may be.
All that is pure speculation of course. I very much doubt that this device exists. I have not even heard of any kind of design/principle that would even theoretically work at these small scales.
I mean there is absolutely nothing to support this story, beyond some hearsay...
I would guess that with sufficient funding, you can work arround it.How exactly are they keeping their tritium needs secret?
I also guess that they dont need that much of it. If the device is that small and they are only testing it in pulses long enough to get the information they need, who knows how little this really may be.
All that is pure speculation of course. I very much doubt that this device exists. I have not even heard of any kind of design/principle that would even theoretically work at these small scales.
Hold on guys, I think I know who they are. I had this bell ringing in mind all the day, in the end I remembered:
http://www.starscientific.com.au
I covered them before, they are the BLP/Steorn/Eestor of Australia, the pioneers in Muon Catalysed Fusion and lot of other baseless claims.
If you check the various pages it looks a perfect fit to what was written in the report.
The crowd of snake oil salesmen is getting bigger and bigger.
If your local laws allow you to do so, I suggest you start oiling the double barrel gun and charge it with an extra dose of salt, just in case someone comes to ring to your door offering some amazing investment scheme.
http://www.starscientific.com.au
I covered them before, they are the BLP/Steorn/Eestor of Australia, the pioneers in Muon Catalysed Fusion and lot of other baseless claims.
If you check the various pages it looks a perfect fit to what was written in the report.
The crowd of snake oil salesmen is getting bigger and bigger.
If your local laws allow you to do so, I suggest you start oiling the double barrel gun and charge it with an extra dose of salt, just in case someone comes to ring to your door offering some amazing investment scheme.